Harry McCracken
From the December 2000 issue of PC World
magazine
Posted Friday, October 27, 2000
It's like Winston Churchill said: The Web
browser is the worst way to navigate the Net...except for all
the others. Well, okay, he was really comparing democracy to
other forms of government, but you get the idea. Internet
Explorer and Netscape Navigator have faults aplenty, but
ultimately, they work.
Maybe that's why so many radical
alternatives to browsing have died on the vine. (Anyone
remember Microsoft's Active Desktop?) But while trying to
replace the browser seems to be a fool's errand, reinventing
it is another matter. A bunch of new tools do just that, each
in its own ingenious way. And although not one of them is
perfect, each is worth a try.
The Urge to Merge
Right now, I'm perusing a single Web page
bursting with news from the Washington Post, the
Times of London, CNN, NBC, and my hometown paper. I
engineered this media megamerger myself, thanks to Quickbrowse.com. This site stitches Web
pages together into a single, extralong page you can browse or
receive via e-mail. You can piece together one of these pages
out of any set of URLs you specify (which is what I did), or
choose sites from ready-made lists in categories such as
business, stocks, entertainment, and comic strips.
In short, a Quickbrowse page is an
all-you-can-eat content buffet piled high with stuff from your
favorite sites. The info-glutton in me loves to dig in. Still,
it takes a lot of scrolling to traverse a megapage that
consists of three, four, or more Web pages in their entirety.
That's even more true when those pages are already larded with
text, graphics, links, and ads.
So ultimately, I prefer the pickier
approach that Octopus permits. Maybe all you really need
from Lycos's superbusy home page is the search box. Fine--just
grab it (using a button that Octopus installs on your browser)
and plunk it on a custom page. That page (a view, in
Octopus parlance) can also contain bits and pieces of content
from all over the Web--weather forecasts, sports scoreboards,
news headlines, and anything else you care to snag. Views have
a refreshingly minimalist feel, since they consist entirely of
items you've chosen, and Octopus tends to strip out ads,
colors, and graphics. (Click a link you've included in your
view, though, and Octopus launches a new browser window and
dumps you at the originating site.)
Octopus users have published scads of
views for public consumption, most of which pull together
disparate content on a single topic, be it alien abductions or
Ziggy Marley. But as far as I'm concerned, the best way to use
Octopus is to weave together subjects that have nothing in
common, except that you're interested in them. (My favorite
view combines stuff on old wristwatches and Burt Bacharach
with the contents of my Yahoo Mail in-box.)
The Web was never meant to be so
malleable, so it's a wonder that Octopus works at all--and
truth to tell, it only works most of the time.
Sometimes I can't pry a Web element loose from its originating
page; other times elements don't function properly after I've
deposited them in a view. And even when Octopus operates as
advertised, it still requires some studying and fiddling.
The same caveats apply--only more so--to
a couple of its rivals. OnePage resembles Octopus in feel and
features, but it's a tad less flexible and less intuitive
overall. Meanwhile, DataBites is stuffed with tantalizing tools:
It can display bite-size chunks of Web content in unobtrusive
desktop windows, and shuttle those content chunks to a PDA or
Web-ready cell phone. The beta version I tried was certainly
promising, but also tricky to figure out and prone to crashes.
(Check the DataBites Web site to see if a more polished update
is available.)
All-in-Onespace
Finally, there's Enfish's Onespace. Part
personal information manager, part file manager, and part
browser, this free, exceptionally powerful Windows application
herds together Web pages, office documents, contacts, e-mail
messages, appointments, and probably some other items I'm
forgetting right now. It does all this via bookmarklike links
that tie related items together via multiple tabbed windows.
Onespace does many things that
traditional PIMs can't. However, the sheer range of its
features can prove daunting, and its idiosyncratic interface
doesn't help. So at times, I have to agree with Churchill's
verdict: Onespace is a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an
enigma.
All right, he was really talking about
Russia. But you get the idea.
FYI
So long, snail mail? In a new survey, 80
percent of respondents say that e-mail has replaced postal
delivery for most of their business correspondence.
Source: Vault.com
E-mail PC World Executive
Editor Harry McCracken at mailto:websavvy@pcworld.com